How does a court decide whether to grant a motion to suppress evidence?

The court uses a four-part test to decide whether evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution should be suppressed. This test, known as the “exclusionary rule,” considers: (1) whether the person’s Fourth Amendment rights were violated; (2) whether the violation was serious enough that the evidence should be excluded; (3) whether the police officers acted in good faith; and (4) whether excluding the evidence would serve the public interest. In California, when a defendant files a motion to suppress evidence, the court reviews the facts and circumstances surrounding the search and seizure of the evidence. The defendant must show that the police officers had no reasonable cause to search or seize the defendant’s property. If the court determines that the police officers lacked probable cause, then the court may grant the motion to suppress the evidence. The court may also evaluate whether the evidence was secured in good faith. The officer’s state of mind and conduct at the time of the search are taken into consideration when determining whether the officer was acting in good faith. This means that the court will examine whether the officer reasonably relied on the facts and circumstances available to him or her at the time of the search. Finally, the court considers the potential effect that exclusion of the evidence would have on public safety and justice. If the court determines that the exclusion of the evidence would undermine a legitimate law enforcement purpose, then the court may deny the motion to suppress the evidence.

Related FAQs

What is a drug conspiracy?
What is an illicit drug?
What is the difference between a plea of guilty and a guilty plea?
What is the difference between a plea agreement and a plea bargain?
What is the exclusionary rule?
What rights do defendants have in a criminal trial?
What is the difference between intent to sell and possession for sale?
What is the difference between a mandatory minimum sentence and a maximum sentence?
What evidence is used to prove a drug crime?
What is an informant in a drug crime case?

How does a court decide whether to grant a motion to suppress evidence?

Related FAQs

Related Blog Posts