Is a person allowed to use the defense of fair comment in a defamation case?

In California, a person is allowed to use the defense of fair comment in a defamation case. The defense of fair comment, also sometimes known as a "fair report privilege," allows a person to express their opinion without fear of liability for defamation. The defense of fair comment requires that the opinion which the accused expressed is an opinion about a matter of public interest; that the opinion is based upon true facts; that the opinion is genuinely held; and that the person accused is not motivated by malice. The purpose of this defense is to ensure that people can contribute to public discourse without fear of being sued for expressing their opinion. This is done by balancing the right to freedom of speech with the right of the plaintiff to protect their reputation from unwanted attacks by false accusations. When fair comment is used as a defense in a defamation case, the burden is on the accused to prove that the facts underlying the opinion are true and that their opinion is genuinely held. The accused must also show that they were not motivated by malicious intent when they expressed their opinion. If the accused is able to demonstrate these things, then their fair comment defense will likely be successful.

Related FAQs

Are there any restrictions on the type of evidence that can be used in a defamation case?
Is a person required to prove actual malice to win a defamation claim?
How do you prove the public impact of a statement in a defamation case?
If a statement is true, is it still considered defamatory?
Is it possible for a person to retract a statement before filing a defamation lawsuit?
Are websites protected from liability for content published by its users?
What is the difference between public and private figures in a defamation claim?
How do you determine the difference between a “public concern” and a “private concern” in a defamation lawsuit?
What happens in a defamation case if the defendant does not have sufficient assets?
What is the difference between defamation per se and defamation per quod?

Is a person allowed to use the defense of fair comment in a defamation case?

Related FAQs

Related Blog Posts