What is the difference between mandatory and discretionary sentencing?

Mandatory sentencing involves a judge imposing a minimum sentence, or “mandatory minimum”, for a crime. This sentence is dictated by law and cannot be changed by the judge. In Virginia, punishments for certain violent offenses such as murder and rape can include life in prison without the possibility of parole. Discretionary sentencing occurs when a judge is allowed to use their judgement in determining the appropriate sentence for a crime. Judges take into account factors such as the seriousness of the offense, the defendant’s criminal history, and mitigating circumstances when making their decision. Virginia does not have many mandatory sentences, so discretionary sentencing is the most common form of sentencing for criminal offenses. The biggest difference between mandatory and discretionary sentencing is the amount of flexibility that the judge has when determining a sentence. With mandatory sentencing, the judge must follow the guidelines set out by law, while with discretionary sentencing they have more freedom to tailor the sentence to the individual circumstances of the case. Ultimately, the goal of both forms of sentencing is to ensure that justice is served.

Related FAQs

What is the role of the judge during a criminal trial?
What is the process of lineups, interrogations, and confessions in criminal proceedings?
What is the difference between criminal and civil procedure?
What is the process of a criminal appeals court?
What is the difference between a direct and an indirect appeal?
What are the rights of victims in criminal proceedings?
What is the impact of Miranda v. Arizona on criminal procedure?
What is the difference between mandatory and discretionary sentencing?
What is the role of the prosecution in a criminal case?
What is the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor?

Related Blog Posts

An Overview of Constitutional Protections in Criminal Procedure - July 31, 2023
The Requirements and Benefits of Proper Criminal Procedure - August 7, 2023
Understanding the Right to Remain Silent in Criminal Procedure - August 14, 2023
What You Should Know About the Exclusionary Rule in Criminal Procedure - August 21, 2023
A Look at the Role of Probable Cause in Criminal Procedure - August 28, 2023